Vicki Brautigan Case: Arrest, Charges & More Info

Can a seemingly ordinary life mask a dark secret, a chilling capacity for violence? The case of Vicki Lynne Brautigan, now Vicki McWethy Smither, reveals a shocking narrative of murder, legal battles, and a quest for exoneration that has captivated and divided a community.

The story began to unfold in the summer of 2020, when David Clark was discovered fatally shot in his Millville home on June 14. The investigation led authorities to Vicki Brautigan, then 64 years old, residing in Centerville, Ohio. Nearly five months after Clark's death, she was arrested and subsequently indicted on a slew of charges: murder, burglary, and evidence tampering. The Woodford County, Kentucky, grand jury played a crucial role in bringing these charges against her. The Versailles Police Department officially announced the arrest, linking Brautigan to the crime scene at Clark's Millville residence. Following her arrest, Brautigan was held in the Montgomery Jail in Ohio, awaiting further legal proceedings. The initial sentence handed down to Brautigan was later contested. Just two days after receiving her sentence, her attorney filed a motion to vacate the sentence and withdraw her guilty plea, signaling a determined fight against the conviction. This move added another layer of complexity to an already intricate case.